Overview
A company facing a design patent infringement claim in China may need to defend not only the alleged similarity between the products, but also whether it actually carried out the specific acts alleged by the patent owner.
This distinction was central to a dispute before the Guangzhou Intellectual Property Court, in which a foreign audio equipment manufacturer claimed that a Chinese electronics technology company and an individual had infringed its registered design patent covering a loudspeaker product.
The claimant sought an injunction, joint compensation of approximately RMB 500,000, and litigation costs.
NEO-ARK Law Firm represented the defendants. The defense challenged the connection between the claimant's evidence and the defendants' actual business activities, questioned whether the product images were sufficient for a proper design comparison, and disputed the basis for the claimed compensation.
The court ultimately found that the defendants had engaged in offering the allegedly infringing product for sale and that the product was similar to the patented design. However, the court did not find that the defendants had manufactured or sold the infringing products. It ordered the defendants to cease the infringing conduct, remove the relevant content from their website, and pay joint compensation. The claimant's remaining claims were dismissed.
The case demonstrates the importance of separating different types of alleged infringing conduct and carefully examining the evidence supporting a design patent infringement claim.
Case Snapshot
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Case Type | Design Patent Infringement |
| Practice Area | Intellectual Property Litigation |
| Court | Guangzhou Intellectual Property Court |
| Client | Chinese electronics technology company and individual defendant |
| Opposing Party | Foreign audio equipment manufacturer |
| Product | Loudspeaker |
| Claim Value | Approximately RMB 500,000 |
| Attorney | Yu Yuting |
| Law Firm | NEO-ARK Law Firm |
| Key Issues | Design similarity, evidence of manufacturing and sales, offers for sale, and damages |
| Outcome | Infringement found in relation to offering for sale; manufacturing and sales were not established |
Key Legal Issues
1. Does Evidence of an Online Product Listing Prove Manufacturing or Sales?
A design patent infringement claim should distinguish between different types of commercial conduct, including manufacturing, selling, and offering products for sale.
Evidence that a product appears on a company's website does not necessarily establish that the company manufactured or completed a sale of that product. The court must assess the evidence in relation to the specific conduct alleged and the relevant defendant.
In this case, the claimant relied on website content and project-related materials to support its allegations. The defense argued that certain materials predated the establishment of the defendant company and therefore could not establish that the company had carried out the alleged activities.
The court ultimately did not find that the defendants had manufactured or sold the infringing products, although it found that offering the product for sale had occurred.
This distinction was important because the scope of established conduct directly affected the extent of the defendants' potential liability.
2. How Should a Court Compare the Allegedly Infringing Product With a Registered Design?
Design patent infringement analysis requires an assessment of the overall visual effect of the allegedly infringing product compared with the patented design.
The defense challenged the claimant's reliance on limited product images, arguing that a single view could not adequately establish the full appearance of the product. The arguments addressed the visibility and consistency of particular design features, including the speaker grille and internal structural details.
The defense also questioned whether the claimant's comparison adequately accounted for the product's overall appearance and the relevant design features.
A proper design comparison should not rely on an isolated feature or an incomplete image where the available evidence does not allow the overall visual effect to be assessed reliably. The precise comparison method depends on the registered design materials, the accused product, and the applicable legal standards.
In this case, the court ultimately found the products similar to the patented design. The defense therefore did not eliminate the infringement finding, but its arguments formed part of the broader dispute over the scope and degree of similarity.
3. Can Evidence From Earlier Projects Be Attributed to a Company Established Later?
The timing and identity of the parties involved in the alleged conduct can be critical in intellectual property litigation.
The claimant relied on certain historical project materials to support its allegations. The defense argued that these materials were created before the defendant company was established and did not establish that the company or the individual defendant had carried out the alleged manufacturing or sales activities.
The defense also challenged the reliability of certain evidence by referring to an earlier judgment involving the claimant's evidentiary materials.
These arguments focused the court's attention on whether the submitted documents could reliably establish the defendants' own conduct, rather than merely showing that similar products or projects had existed at an earlier time.
4. How Can a Defendant Challenge an Excessive Damages Claim?
The claimant sought substantial compensation, but the defense disputed the basis and calculation of the alleged losses.
In particular, the defense challenged the claimant's unilateral pricing assumptions and the evidentiary support for its damages calculation.
In intellectual property litigation, the amount claimed by a patent owner is not automatically the amount recoverable. The court must assess the available evidence and apply the relevant statutory rules for determining compensation.
The defense therefore focused on limiting the damages assessment to what could be supported by the established facts and applicable legal standards.
The court ultimately awarded compensation substantially below the amount claimed and dismissed the claimant's remaining requests.
Legal Strategy
| Issue | Defense Approach | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Attribution of historical materials | Examined the dates of the project materials and the establishment of the defendant company | Challenged whether earlier activities could be attributed to the defendants |
| Scope of alleged conduct | Distinguished manufacturing, completed sales, and offers for sale | Helped limit the conduct established by the court |
| Evidentiary reliability | Challenged the reliability and verifiability of certain materials, including by reference to an earlier judgment | Questioned whether the claimant's evidence sufficiently established the allegations |
| Design comparison | Examined the available product views and disputed whether they adequately demonstrated the overall visual similarity | Highlighted limitations in the claimant's comparison evidence |
| Damages | Challenged the claimant's valuation assumptions and supporting evidence | Helped resist the full compensation claim |
Court's Decision and Outcome
The Guangzhou Intellectual Property Court found that the accused product was similar to the patented design and that the defendants had engaged in offering the product for sale.
However, the court did not establish that the defendants had manufactured or sold the infringing products.
The court ordered the defendants to:
- Cease the infringing conduct;
- Remove the relevant allegedly infringing content from their website; and
- Pay joint compensation.
The court dismissed the claimant's remaining claims.
The judgment did not order destruction of the products. The compensation awarded was substantially lower than the amount originally claimed.
The outcome was therefore a partial success for the defense: although the court found infringement in relation to offering for sale, the claimant did not establish all the alleged forms of commercial conduct or obtain the full relief requested.
Practical Lessons for Companies Facing Design Patent Claims in China
Distinguish the Alleged Infringing Acts
Manufacturing, selling, and offering products for sale are distinct forms of conduct. A defendant should examine whether the evidence actually establishes each alleged act and whether it can be attributed to the relevant company or individual.
Examine the Dates and Origin of Evidence
Historical website content, project records, and third-party materials should be assessed in light of the defendant's establishment date, business activities, and actual involvement. Earlier records should not automatically be treated as proof of later conduct by a particular company.
Assess the Complete Design, Not Just Isolated Features
Design patent disputes require an appropriate comparison of the overall visual effect. Parties should examine the registered design documents and the accused product from the perspectives supported by the available evidence.
Challenge Unsupported Damages Calculations
A claimant's requested compensation should be examined against the applicable legal rules and the evidence supporting the claimed loss or other relevant calculation basis. A substantial claim does not guarantee an equivalent award.
Consider the Practical Scope of the Judgment
Even where a court finds infringement, the specific orders may be narrower than the claimant's requests. Businesses should assess the actual conduct found by the court, the scope of the injunction, and the financial consequences when planning their response.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a company be liable for design patent infringement in China if it only offers a product for sale?
Potentially, yes. Offering a product for sale may constitute an independently actionable form of conduct under China's patent law. However, whether infringement is established depends on the product, the patent rights involved, the evidence, and the circumstances of the offer.
Does a website listing prove that a company manufactured or sold an infringing product?
Not necessarily. A website listing may be relevant to whether a product was offered for sale, but it does not automatically prove that the company manufactured the product or completed a sale. The court must assess the evidence supporting each alleged act.
How does a Chinese court compare an accused product with a design patent?
The comparison generally focuses on the overall visual effect of the accused product and the patented design, taking account of the relevant design features and the applicable legal standards. The court considers the registered design materials and the evidence of the accused product rather than relying solely on an isolated feature.
Can a defendant challenge evidence relating to projects completed before its establishment?
Yes. The timing, origin, authenticity, and connection of the evidence to the defendant are relevant considerations. Materials predating a company's establishment do not automatically establish that the company carried out the alleged conduct.
Can a patent owner recover the full amount claimed in a design patent lawsuit?
Not automatically. The court determines compensation under the applicable legal rules and the evidence available. A defendant may challenge unsupported valuation assumptions and the factual basis for the amount claimed.
Conclusion
This case illustrates why a design patent defense in China should examine more than whether an accused product resembles a registered design.
The court must also assess what conduct the defendant actually carried out, whether the evidence can be attributed to that defendant, and whether the claimant's damages calculation is adequately supported.
Although the court found that the defendants had offered a similar product for sale, it did not establish manufacturing or completed sales and awarded substantially less than the amount claimed.
For companies facing design patent litigation in China, a focused defense addressing conduct, evidence, design comparison, and damages can materially affect the scope and consequences of the judgment.
About the Author

Yu Yuting
Partner | NEO-ARK Law Firm
Lawyer Yu focuses on foreign-related litigation, cross-border disputes, commercial matters, and legal services for overseas individuals and businesses in China.
Email: [email protected]
About NEO-ARK Law Firm
NEO-ARK Law Firm provides legal services in foreign-related litigation, commercial disputes, family law, and cross-border legal matters, assisting both international and domestic clients throughout China.








